Book Reviews

Pictures of Hollis Woods, Reviewed by Faith, 11

S for sister and B for brother. M for mom, and D For dad. F for family, and W for wish. Hollis Woods is a headstrong, smart, and talented girl. She is an orphan, and she is constantly running away from her foster homes. This realistic-fiction story goes back and forth between the pictures Hollis draws of her memories, and real life events almost 1 year later. Hollis usually only stays at a foster home for a few weeks at a time, but one of her foster families is different… the Reagans: Izzy, The Old Man, and Steven. Hollis stays with them for a whole summer in their house in Branches, where she finally feels that she belongs. But, a tragic event happens, and Hollis runs away from the only family she’s ever known. Now, she lives with Josie, a retired art teacher with a secret. As she gets to know Josie more and more, Hollis realizes that she has to stay with Josie and help her keep her secret. While Hollis is staying with Josie, she finds out a little bit more about her. Josie carves people out of wood, she has a fiesty cat named Henry, and she has a cousin named Beatrice. When Beatrice visits New Mexico, Hollis stays with Josie. But, when the lady from the foster home finds out about Josie’s secret, she makes it her number one priority to remove Hollis from Josie’s care. Then, Hollis has to make the decision to stay with Josie, or run away from her problems. I can relate to Hollis because I loved my old school. It was my favorite out of all of the ones I’ve been to. But, my dad lost his job and since he didn’t work there anymore, I had to go to public school. Most of my friends went there, so I was kind of excited. Now I love my new school, and if I had the choice to back to my old school, I would probably say no. Public school is much closer and cheaper for my family anyway. I love this book because I like how Patricia Reilly Giff goes back and forth between real life, and Hollis’s pictures. It’s hard to imagine how Hollis just runs away from her foster homes without a trace. Even if they weren’t my real family, I still would stay with them. Hollis must really feel alone and scared. I mean, how would you feel if you had to sleep under the boardwalk sometimes! My favorite part of the book was at the end, when everything comes together. But, then again, that’s probably the best part of most stories! All in all, I give this book 4¾ stars out of 5. The book was amazing, but some parts were confusing, and weren’t explained at the end. Other than that, the book was filled with suspense and mystery. It displayed many examples of foreshadowing, so you have to look at the little details. If you would get confused going back and forth in time, this book may not be for you. In my opinion, the theme of this book was not to run away from your problems, but to face them head-on. Sometimes you will go through rough times in life, but in the end you will work it all out if you persevere. Pictures of Hollis Woods by Patricia Reilly Giff. Yearling Books, 2004. Buy the book here and support Stone Soup in the process! Have you read this book? Or do you plan on reading it? Let us know in the comments below!

Stargirl, Reviewed by Keira Olson, 11

Stargirl is a beautifully written book by Jerry Spinelli. It tells about being different, and the problems and joy of a first love. Stargirl is written for seventh to ninth graders, but adults will love it too! Stargirl is one of my favorite books because of the way Jerry Spinelli describes the characters emotions, and the setting. He uses phrases like, “She laughed, and the desert sang,” and, “The ground does have a sandy color to it, or gray, but your feet won’t sink in.” I can relate to Stargirl because she is different, and isn’t everyone? This book made me realize that being different doesn’t mean that everyone necessarily wants to fit in, like in most books. When Stargirl is asked by her friend, Leo, to become normal, she tries once to be like everyone else, and goes back to being herself, which I find very inspiring. The story takes place at Mica High, in the town of Mica, where everyone acts, and dresses the same. On Stargirl’s first day, she showed up dressed in a long white gown, with a ukulele strapped to her back. Her classmates were in awe, and out of shock, and admiration, she instantly became very popular. Classmates dressed like her, and acted like her, but nothing lasts forever… Leo Borlock fell in love with her almost immediately. They went on adventures together, and had a great time, until he realized that no one was talking to either of them, but Stargirl didn’t seem to notice or care. When classmates turned on Stargirl, and Leo pleaded that she become normal, will Stargirl stay different, and be herself? I hope that the first chance you get, you will read Stargirl. You will never look at a rat, a cactus, or a billboard the same again. So now that you’ve read my book review, go read Stargirl! Stargirl by Jerry Spinelli. Ember Books, Reprint 2002. Buy the book here and support Stone Soup in the process! Have you read this book? Or do you plan on reading it? Let us know in the comments below!

Taking Flight with Soman Chainani

Since I was small, I have been a passionate reader, instantly drawn into stories that could be painted in words. When I discovered chapter books, I remember eagerly awaiting the moment when I could open a book and slip into its vivid colors and images. In an instant, I might feel the brush of rainbow-colored wind on my cheeks or hear the clear sound of river water gliding over rocks. The moment I finished a book, I couldn’t wait to pick up another one to take yet another leap into the world of an author’s imagination where it could be mixed with my own imagination, as if we were telling the story together as I read. This journey has always felt kind of like an instantly departing airplane, except that I never had to worry about how long until the plane reached its final destination. I could just enjoy the journey, and adapt to new places as I went, experiencing love, fear, danger, and courage through the eyes of other characters. And The School for Good and Evil by Soman Chainani was the first book, in particular, to show me how powerful my imagination was in being able to empathize with experiences that seemed entirely different but still somehow linked to my own.   Since discovering The School for Good and Evil in fourth grade, I’ve read it seventeen times, and each time I open it up, I become instantly fascinated by the elaborate personalities of each character and the special powers they possessed, like the ability to cast spells with their glowing fingertips or concoct herbal potions that allowed for shape-shifting and falling in love. I couldn’t believe that a single author had created a world that was full of magic but still felt as real and true as my own life. I became determined to find out everything I could about his background as a writer, and on his website, I learned that not only had all his books had made it onto the New York Times Bestseller list, but his first series had been translated into twenty-seven languages across six different continents and was now being made into a movie by Universal Pictures. I was even more surprised to learn that Soman Chainani found enough time to work on writing his novels and screenplays while still playing tennis competitively in New York City. Up until that day, I had assumed that to be really good at something, you had to give everything else up in order to reach your goal. At least that was how I’d always viewed playing violin myself. Starting when I was small, I’ve devoted myself to practicing up to three hours every day, and ever since joining an international string ensemble last year, I’ve had to spend most weekends and at least two nights a week rehearsing. Soman Chainani was the first person to open up my mind to the possibility of writing a novel despite all of my other activities. If he had managed to make his dreams happen as a writer, filmmaker, and athlete, then maybe I could balance my passions for writing and music too. I decided that I would find time to write. My goal was to write for at least twenty minutes a day a few times week in the morning before school or after I finished my homework in the evening.  I started off by writing poems and short pieces in response to writing prompts, and then slowly worked my way up to my first fantasy fiction novel. I didn’t know where to start with the story, exactly, but I did know I wanted my new grey tabby kitten named Daisy to be the heroine of my series. I decided to follow Soman Chainani’s lead and create my own imaginary world. I set the story in a large floating city named Skyworld that hovers above New York. In the opening pages, Daisy embarks on a journey to find her long-lost brother, Jacob. Along the way, she meets a wide cast of characters, many of them inspired by those found in The School for Good and Evil. But when I finished the first draft, a teacher told me I would need to ask Soman Chainani’s permission to use several of his character names in my own work. I was scared and nervous to email a famous author out of the blue, but relieved when just a few weeks later, Soman wrote me back, encouraging me to use the names of his characters as I continued writing. I was overjoyed to know that I wouldn’t have to change my story and could move forward in plotting the next story I had in mind for these characters, in working toward creating my very own series.  Looking back, I realize that Soman Chainani has inspired me in more ways than one.  Not only has he inspired my desire to write, but he has shown me that being an author also means being there for your readers.  When some authors become famous, they might not take time out of their packed days to answer emails or requests, but Soman isn’t this way. He seems humble, kind, and supportive of his fans, and he wants them to feel motivated to do the hard work of writing an original story. If I become a published author one day, I hope to be there for my readers too, answering their questions and encouraging them to follow their dreams. Soman reminds me that being an author is about small, daily habits that add up in big ways. He has taught me that writing isn’t about making money or becoming famous, but it is about sitting down to make the time to write no matter what. I realized that as long as I can carve out this space, not only am I setting my mind free to build exciting new worlds out of my imagination, but in the process I might inspire others to do the same.