fbpx

Abhi Sukhdial

The Breadwinner, Reviewed by Abhi Sukhdial, 10

“Life isn’t always fair.” Remember that when you watch The Breadwinner. On the long Emirates flight to India, there were a lot of movies to choose from, but this one caught my attention. Emirates even recommends the movie! The Breadwinner is a 2017 animated drama about a poor family under Taliban rule. After her father mistakenly gets captured, Parvana, an 11-year old girl (and the story’s main character!) cuts off her hair to look like a boy. Why? Because even today, in many parts of the world, girls don’t have the same rights as boys. As a boy, she is able to go freely to the market and buy groceries to support her family. At times, the movie is very exciting and fun, but there are also some very scary scenes that show her family members as well as random people getting beaten and whipped. Even though this is an animated story, it’s not like the Disney movies. I felt very sad and mad after watching it – sad to see the suffering of kids and adults… and mad that today, people can treat each other like that. This movie has a lot of great themes, like teamwork, bravery, kindness, and grit. It really shows that even in the darkest of times, we can still look for hope and light. Most adults and even us kids will face difficult problems in our lives. But we can always figure out how to solve them. I’ve faced many hard challenges (but not as bad as Parvana’s!). However, this movie has a downside, and that is the way the story ends. It wasn’t really surprising and shocking, and not as creative and satisfying as I had hoped. I don’t want to be a spoiler, so go see the movie for yourself to learn more! Regardless, The Breadwinner is extremely good, and I’m not the only one who thinks so. This movie was nominated for an Oscar for Best Animated Featured Film. I recommend all tweens (10-13 years old) to watch this movie. The Breadwinner (2017) was based on the best-selling novel of the same name by Deborah Ellis (published in 2014). The animated film was made by Cartoon Saloon. Director: Nora Twomey. Executive producers Mimi Polk Gitlin and Angelina Jolie.

Summer Journal 2018: Abhimanyu Sukhdial’s family visit to India

Stone Soup book reviewer and artist Abhi Sukhdial, age 10, has sent us the first two pages of his summer journal. He is on a family visit to northern India for two-and-a-half months, visiting family outside of Delhi. Click through to read both pages of the journal Abhimanyu Sukhdial’s Summer Journal 2018, page 1 Abhimanyu Sukhdial’s Summer Journal 2018, page 2 Transcript Page 1: Summer Journal 2018 Portrait Our summer vacation was to go to India, and it was just what I expected. I’ve been going to India since I was two months old and everything is the same. My thoughts about going there were “Is anything different?” The main reason we go to India is to meet my grandmother. She lives alone with her dog (Toffee), and a maid that helps her out. Most of the time in India, I play games and do all my work, My favourite thing though is spending time with my brother and dad. In India everything is different compared to America (Including the taste of food)! Life is hard in India. People can’t find jobs, can’t make any money which is a little sad. But on the bright side my grandmother has a huge garden in her frontward! She mainly has a LOT Page 2: of mango trees. Sleeping at a good time is a rare occurrence for me here because I usually sleep at 11:00 P.M. But THAT doesn’t ruin my vacation. What does is the AIR-CONDITIONING. It sometimes goes on and off which is really annoying. Regardless, that even doesn’t make me hate my vacation. The thing is, nothing ruins my summer vacation! There are three bedrooms in this house, 1 for my grandmother, 1 for me and my dad, and 1 for my mom and brother. The maid sleeps on the floor. There are 2 bathrooms, a dining room, and a kitchen. So to be honest, my grandmother’s house is big on the outside and big on the inside. We never travel ANYWHERE once we reach my grandmother’s house. For the whole vacation, our family and I relax in my grandmother’s house. Which I’m a BIG fan of. The travel on the plane is long. We have to ride 14 hrs on the first plane, and 3 hours on the second plane. But I got to watch A LOT of movies. Here are some pictures from the garden [3 drawings]: mangoes hanging on a tree          fish statue          prickly plant   About the author: Abhimanyu Sukhdial, age 10Stillwater, OK              

The Crossover, Reviewed by Abhi Sukhdial, 10

Have you read a 200-page book full of poetry? Well my guess is no. but if you WANT to read one, I have the perfect book for you! It’s the one and only The Crossover, a novel in verse. I am a big fan of basketball; I sometimes shoot hoops during school recess. Based on my own experience, I know basketball is not just about winning. It’s not easy to do basketball; it’s not easy to do anything. Even if you are the best of the best. The Crossover follows the story of Josh Bell (aka Filthy Mcnasty) and Jordan Bell (aka JB) as they play basketball and go on with their normal middle school lives. Each is talented in his own way, but together they’re unstoppable. When they were young, they were the best of brothers and friends, but over the course of this novel, their relationship becomes strained. But even if they argue or are mean to each other, they are still brothers. And their dad, a former professional basketball player, wants his sons to follow in his footsteps. This book is about friendship and grit. Josh emulates the kind of courage we would all like to have – the courage to fail, and to believe that it is OK to lose. Josh doesn’t give up; he just gets up the next day and practices even harder for the next game. But for a really good book, there are also some cons. This book mainly focuses on basketball, which is not always a good thing, unless you REALLY understand the language of basketball (e.g. swish, swoop, crossover). In addition, the novel in verse format is challenging – you have to pay attention to the sounds of the words, the way the words are written on the page, and the way one poem flows on to the next. This book is also pretty sad at times (I don’t want to give more details because that would be a spoiler!). Finally, one of the problems I have with the story is that it is ONLY told from Josh’s perspective—if some of the poems were written from the father’s or JB point of view, then I would be able to better understand their emotions and that would make the story more interesting. This book was written by Kwame Alexander in 2014 and won the Newbery Medal in 2015 (Yay!). One of my favorite passages is: “I watch the ball leave his hands like a bird up high, skating the sky, crossing over us.” So if anyone is looking for an emotional, but exciting book to read, try The Crossover. The Crossover by Kwame Alexander. HMH Books for Young Readers, 2014. Buy the book here and support Stone Soup in the process! Have you read this book? Or do you plan on reading it? Let us know in the comments below!